A nontechnical winter key to the fifty trees 
  | 
  |
| 1. Leaves persistent and green throughout the winter, needle-shaped, awl-shaped, or scaly (see summer key). | |
| 1. Leaves deciduous, not remaining on trees throughout winter. | |
2. Twigs with lateral wart-like branches, slender, glossy brown, resinous.  | 
    (28) American Larch | 
2. Twigs lacking lateral wart-like branches.  | 
  |
3. Arrangement of branches, leaf scars, and buds opposite.  | 
  |
4. Twig stout, gray to brown in color; buds brown or black (ashes).  | 
  |
5. Buds rusty brown;
    bark dark brown, corky in texture with  | 
    (3) White Ash | 
5. Buds usually black; bark ashy gray without ridges, scaling off easily.  | 
    (2) Black Ash | 
4. Twigs slender, red to brown; buds red or brown (maples).  | 
  |
6. Buds narrow, sharp-pointed, brown.  | 
    (33) Sugar Maple | 
6. Buds broad, blunt-pointed, reddish color, often clustered.  | 
    |
7. Twigs lacking odor when broken.  | 
    (31) Red Maple | 
7. Fresh twigs with rank odor when broken.  | 
    (32) Silver Maple | 
3. Arrangement of branches, leaf scars, and buds alternate.  | 
  |
8. Terminal bud absent (first lateral bud may seem terminal but is not).  | 
  |
9. Bud with only one scale, forming cap over bud.  | 
  |
10. Twigs stout, zigzagging, brown.  | 
    (47) Sycamore | 
10. Twigs slender, not zigzagging, green to brown.  | 
    (50) Black Willow | 
9. Bud with many scales.  | 
  |
11. Buds very small, inconspicuous; twigs with spines or thorns.  | 
  |
12. Twigs usually bearing spines in pairs at nodes; twigs slender, reddish to greenish brown, brittle.  | 
    (29) Black Locust | 
12. Twigs usually bearing branched thorns; twigs stout, zigzagging, smooth, glossy.  | 
    (30) Honey-Locust | 
11. Buds medium to large, conspicuous; twigs lacking spines or thorns.  | 
  |
13. Buds lopsided or bulging on one side at the base, green to red; twigs zigzagging.  | 
    (6) Basswood | 
13. Buds symmetrical, lacking bulge at base, brown; twigs not zigzagging.  | 
  |
14. Twigs stout, pith star-shaped.  | 
    (15) American Chestnut | 
14. Twigs slender, pith circular.  | 
  |
15. Bark of trunk scaly.  | 
  |
16. Scales easily removed when rubbed.  | 
    (26) American Hophornbeam | 
16. Scales difficult to remove when rubbed (elms).  | 
  |
17. Buds dark, chestnut-brown, with long rusty hairs at tip; twigs light gray, hairy, mucilaginous when chewed; inner bark of trunk with alternating white and dark layers.  | 
    (19) Slippery Elm | 
17. Buds light red-brown, mostly lacking hairs; twigs red-brown, smooth; inner bark uniform.  | 
    (18) American Elm | 
15. Bark of trunk smooth.  | 
  |
18. Bark dark bluish gray.  | 
    (27) American Hornbeam | 
18. Bark chalky white.  | 
  |
19. Bark peeling off in thin papery layers, lacking triangular patches.  | 
    (10) Paper Birch | 
19. Bark not peeling off in papery layers, with distinct triangular patch below each branch where it joins the stem.  | 
    (9) Gray Birch | 
| 8. Terminal bud present either surrounded by a cluster of buds or borne singly. | |
20. Terminal bud surrounded by a cluster of buds at end of twig; fruit an acorn (oaks).  | 
  |
21. Buds oval or rounded.  | 
    |
22. Buds oval, rather blunt at top, somewhat woolly, especially upper half, red-brown; twigs light red.  | 
    (37) Scarlet Oak | 
22. Buds rounded, blunt-pointed, red-brown.  | 
    (38) White Oak | 
21. Buds sharp-pointed.  | 
  |
23. Buds covered with dense yellow-gray wool.  | 
    (34) Black Oak | 
23. Buds smooth.  | 
    |
24. Buds light yellow-brown; twigs light orange.  | 
    (35) Chestnut Oak | 
24. Buds red-brown; twigs red-brown to green-brown.  | 
    (36) Northern Red Oak | 
20. Terminal bud borne singly. (In the birches only the short spur-like lateral twigs have terminal buds, not the long shoots.)  | 
  |
25. Buds with 3-4 dark brown smooth outer scales spreading away from bud; bark peeling in long strips.  | 
    (25) Shagbark Hickory | 
25. Buds variously colored with various number of scales; flattened against twig or spreading; bark usually tight, not peeling.  | 
  |
26. Buds covered with close-fitting woolly scales.  | 
  |
27. Twigs with chambered pith (walnuts).  | 
  |
28. Pith cream colored; twigs lacking "mustache" of hair beneath bud.  | 
    (49) Black Walnut | 
28. Pith chocolate-colored; twigs with "mustache" of hair beneath bud.  | 
    (12) Butternut | 
27. Twigs solid, lacking chambered pith.  | 
  |
29. Twigs brittle, brown, smooth; buds dark brown.  | 
    (17) Cucumber Tree | 
29. Twigs tough, yellow to red-brown color, hairy toward end; buds yellow.  | 
    (23) Bitternut Hickory | 
26. Bud scales smooth, not woolly.  | 
  |
30. Bud with 2 scales united into a cap; twigs brittle with aromatic odor.  | 
    (48) Tulip Tree | 
30. Bud with more than two scales.  | 
  |
31. Twigs with wintergreen flavor or aroma; terminal bud on spur-like lateral branches only.  | 
  |
32. Twigs with strong wintergreen flavor, red-brown; bark black, smooth, lacking papery fringes.  | 
    (8) Black Birch | 
32. Twigs with slight wintergreen flavor, yellow-brown; bark yellow-gray with papery fringes.  | 
    (11) Yellow Birch | 
31. Twigs lacking wintergreen flavor and aroma; terminal bud on lateral branches.  | 
  |
33. Lateral buds usually same size as terminal bud.  | 
  |
34. Buds usually round, red to chestnut-brown; thorns on twigs.  | 
    (21) Hawthorn | 
34. Buds long, sharp-pointed.  | 
  |
35. Buds tinged with purple; the lateral buds flattened against twig.  | 
    (44) Shadbush | 
35. Buds red-brown, the lateral buds bending away from twig.  | 
    (7) American Beech | 
33. Lateral buds smaller than terminal bud.  | 
  |
36. Bark and twigs spicy aromatic.  | 
    (43) Sassafras | 
36. Bark and twigs odorless or with bitter almond odor, not spicy aromatic.  | 
  |
37. Twigs and bark with bitter almond odor and taste, slender (cherries).  | 
  |
38. Twigs red-brown; bark on trunks becoming scaly.  | 
    (13) Black Cherry | 
38. Twigs bright red; bark remaining smooth; buds very small.  | 
    (14) Pin Cherry | 
37. Twigs lacking bitter almond odor or taste.  | 
  |
39. Twigs very tough; lacking rank odor.  | 
    (24) Pignut Hickory | 
39. Twigs brittle, with rather rank odor when broken (poplars).  | 
  |
40. Lateral buds flattened against twig; twigs slender, red-brown.  | 
    (5) Quaking Aspen | 
40. Lateral buds spreading away from twig; twigs red-brown or yellow.  | 
    |
41. Buds large, shiny, often slightly resinous; twigs bright yellow.  | 
    (16) Eastern Cottonwood | 
41. Buds medium, dull, dusty looking; twigs red-brown.  | 
    (4) Bigtooth Aspen | 
  | 
  |